prof. JUDr. Vladimír Kratochvíl, CSc., poradce Oddělení dokumentace a analytiky judikatury Nejvyššího soudu, e-mail: kratecv@seznam.cz

The article responds to court decisions in the particular case of premeditative murder in terms of committing its forms: Courts I. and II. degrees asses the offense as a juvenile indirect offend, whereas the Appellate Court as a direct offend. The author is led to believe to the lower courts, because the opinion of the Appellate Court seems as discordant with the prohibition of analogy, borne in Criminal Law and subsidiarity of criminal repression.